Freedom of speech is one of humanity’s most cherished values. Everyone is happy to confirm this, particularly when it is their turn to speak. Difficulties generally begin when someone else attempts to exercise the same right.
I am a firm believer in differing opinions myself. After all, how could I persuade anyone if everybody agreed with me in the first place?
As George Orwell put it, “If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.”
Orwell had it easy. He never had to defend his position in a family WhatsApp group.
At a Sunday family lunch, someone cautiously remarked that the soup was perhaps a little salty.
The hostess announced that she was not offended in the slightest. She had been making this soup the same way for thirty years, the family had always loved it, and naturally nobody was obliged to eat it. The guest who had made the remark hastened to clarify that the soup was excellent, just possibly a shade too salty. This made matters considerably worse.
The others promptly assured the hostess that the soup was excellent.
So did the guest who had complained.
Family harmony was restored. The salt content of the soup remained unchanged.
The youngest guest asked why it was impossible simply to say that something tasted salty. The adults explained that honesty mattered, but so did other people’s feelings. The child asked which mattered more.
On that question, no unanimous verdict could be reached.
Among the guests was a man who found this sort of sensitivity particularly irritating. He declared that nowadays you couldn’t say anything any more, everyone took offence at everything, and he, fortunately, had never been one to mince his words.
He looked around expectantly.
Someone then suggested that his new car might not have been a particularly wise purchase.
From that point on, the tone of the conversation changed noticeably.
Honesty is a wonderful quality. Especially when other people have to put up with it.
An acquaintance of mine regularly begins his sentences with “I don’t want to argue”, then spends the next ten minutes explaining why I’m wrong. It’s a polite arrangement, sparing him the unpleasantness of having to call the conversation an argument.
Frankness has developed a peculiar timetable. The truly honest remarks are generally made once the person concerned has left the room. At that point, everyone reaches complete agreement with remarkable speed.
The workings of free speech can also be observed at a football match. There, spectators exercise the right with extraordinary generosity, generally at the expense of the players, the manager and one another.
In the stands, one supporter explained at considerable length that the striker should have been taken off at half-time. The man beside him agreed, and the two soon established that they both understood football exceptionally well.
A few remarks later, it emerged that the stranger supported the opposing team.
The opinion about replacing the striker was immediately reclassified as a provocation.
The supporter leapt to his feet and informed the other man that he would do better to worry about his own team. The stranger shouted back that he had just said exactly the same thing. This only made matters worse.
The people around them joined in, some without the faintest idea what the argument was about.
Meanwhile, the striker had been substituted.
Neither of them noticed.
After the match, the argument could begin afresh in a nearby pub. Within minutes, the people at each table had established exactly how the game should have been played. That the various tables had reached entirely different conclusions troubled nobody.
Every table was unanimous.
Football, however, was merely the warm-up. Twenty minutes later, the world economy, medical science and international diplomacy had all come under discussion. At one table, the world’s most pressing problems were solved by approximately the second round of drinks.
Scientists nowadays must do more than discover the answers. They must also explain them to people who solved the problem themselves the previous evening.
The following day, a short video from the match appeared online.
One commenter concluded from the footage that the manager was incompetent. Another declared that the entire discussion demonstrated a profound ignorance of football. A third objected mainly to the language used by the first two.
A fourth pointed out that the video wasn’t even from yesterday’s match.
Two people liked his comment.
The others carried on arguing.
The person who had uploaded the video later announced that he was always open to reasonable disagreement. Someone asked what evidence might persuade him to change his mind.
No answer was forthcoming, but the questioner was soon accused of acting in bad faith.
One of social media’s more remarkable achievements is that it provides a platform both for people who refuse to reconsider anything and for those who carefully ensure that nobody says anything they would rather not hear.
The division of labour is impeccable. One manufactures the outrage, the other delivers the moral verdict, and then they swap roles.
And, rather remarkably, we are not necessarily talking about two different people.
The same person who demands unlimited freedom of expression in the morning may, by the afternoon, be asking why those who disagree with him are allowed to speak at all.
His principles never waver.
Their application is another matter.
In the workplace, all this is handled somewhat more systematically.
Management encourages open communication and regularly reminds employees that honest feedback is the foundation of progress.
At one meeting, an employee pointed out that the new product did not work.
The manager thanked him for his honesty, then asked whether he might express himself more constructively in future.
The following week, the employee reported that the product offered significant opportunities for further optimisation.
According to the minutes, cooperation had been exemplary.
Three months later, the project failed.
Management was at a loss to understand why nobody had warned them in time.
Fortunately, everyone agreed on that.
Politicians, too, are devoted champions of free speech. Particularly when they are in opposition.
Once in government, they frequently discover that criticism can cause confusion, a question may constitute a provocation, and persistent attempts to obtain an answer are practically a coordinated attack.
Others make unrestricted plain speaking the centrepiece of their political programme. They proudly announce that, unlike everyone else, they say what they think.
An undoubtedly courageous undertaking, particularly when the thinking part is omitted.
The voter is grateful. At last, someone speaks to him like a pub regular, only in a better suit, before a larger audience, and considerably closer to the public purse.
On television, two guests then debate the statement.
One insists that someone has finally had the courage to speak the truth. The other maintains that such a thing should never have been said.
The presenter asks whether it is actually true.
Unfortunately, there is no time for an answer.
It’s time for the adverts.
It would be unfair to equate social disapproval with the silencing of critics by those in power. In some places, a sentence can cost you friends. Elsewhere, it can cost you your freedom.
The difference is particularly clear to anyone sitting in prison.
During an argument, I sometimes find myself composing my reply while the other person is still talking. I’m not so much trying to understand their point of view as searching for the moment when I can finally interrupt.
This is not a particularly effective way of achieving understanding.
It does, however, give an argument considerable momentum.
On one side, every sentence is carefully wrapped to prevent it from bruising anyone’s feelings. On the other, stupidity is shipped in industrial quantities, without packaging, and we are outraged when someone fails to appreciate the gift.
Naturally, everyone remains unwavering in their defence of free speech.
One side defends it against the danger of anyone using it without sufficient caution. The other defends it against the danger of anyone expecting them to think.
We saved freedom of speech.
Unfortunately, the conversation did not survive.


Comments
Loading comments…